Project: How can luxury fashion take the lead for sustainable change?

A deep analyze for luxury companies’ communication strategy methods together with their innovation change to help our sustainable fashion future done (a case analysis of Chinese luxury consumption in Milan and Paris in and after the Covid-19 pandemic)
Keywords: luxury fashion, sustainability, methodology, strategic communication and innovation, SDG12, SCP, luxury consumption, social phenomenon, sustainable design, sustainable economy, climate change, pollution, Chinese consumers, European luxury brands, consumer habits, tourism, fashion consciousness, brand image, Post-Covid-19 era
Abstract
Fashion, as a social phenomenon, a complex study, represents the problem we are facing now and then. “Gradually, the term ‘fashion studies’ has come to refer to the study of fashion in its broad meaning, covering various areas of research across many disciplines, from history, philosophy, sociology, anthropology through to cultural studies, women’s studies, and media studies. Together a range of approaches, from an object-based approach, focused on the materiality of fashion, to a concern with fashion’s more intangible dynamics and underpinnings such as globalization, post-colonialism or its key role as a creative industry” (see, for instance, on globalization, Maynard, 2004; Rabine, 2002, on post-colonialism, Hendrickson, 1996; Root, 2013 on fashion and the creative industries, Rantisi, 2004; Santagata, 2004).
The Covid-19 emerges as the environmental change on our planet. However, it seems not something new to us. Climate change is something we have talked about for a long time. The fashion industry took responsibility for it.
The fashion industry is the second most polluting industry globally, "is also the second-largest consumer of water worldwide, and is responsible for 20% of all industrial water pollution worldwide. The fashion industry's emission makes up more emissions than all international flights, and maritime shipping combined, dries up water sources, and pollutes rivers and streams." (Morgan McFall-Johnsen, 21 Oct 2019, businessinsider.com)
At the fourth industrial revolution, we face overproduction, over-promotion, over-shopping, and over-unnecessary waste in every industry. That represented clearly in the fashion industry. “As consumers worldwide buy more clothes, fast fashion is taking a toll on the environment. On average, people bought 60% more garments in 2014 than they did in 2000; they only kept the clothes for half as long. 85% of all textiles go to the dump each year. Washing some types of clothes sends thousands of bits of plastic into the ocean.
According to a report from the Ellen MacArthur Foundation in 2017: If the fashion sector continues on its current trajectory, that share of the carbon budget could jump to 26% (from 10% right now) by 2050." (Morgan McFall-Johnsen, 21 Oct 2019, businessinsider.com)
The price is one of the key factors for clients to choose their fashion garments. Since the early 2000s, fast-fashion had great success and brought a large amount of pollution and non-environmental friendly influence. Those short-lasting fashion garments are damaging the environment without noticing.
At the top of the pyramid of fashion, Luxury fashion is a group with a completely different meaning; they are usually with limited numbers (hard to obtain, never mass production), better materials, better quality, good design team, and a reason to buy (usually a good story-telling or a legend to tell). However, the price of luxury fashion items is not that friendly. For most consumers, a product that costs more could also be considered valuable, and people would use it in a better way. Those adding value can make luxury fashion garments last much longer. "Luxury products have always been sustainable, but have not been promoted as such.” (Vivian Corporation, 14th Nov 2017) As we can see, many from second-hand stores, luxury fashion garments still have a considerable high value after decades. The existence of luxury fashion could be a way of saving the materials and storing the garments longer. If every customer can use a fashion garment longer, that would already be a sustainable improvement for the environment. “Luxury and sustainability are the same.” Said by François-Henri Pinault (kering.com, 2020)
In this proposal, I am not suggesting people pay thousands of euros for luxury fashion or talk bad about fast-fashion. The proposal is aimed to find the meaning behind luxury fashion, helping both luxury companies and customers to define sustainable luxury fashion. Besides the sense that we know about the fashion luxury industry in a materialistic way, to give them more moral meaning: sustainability is an excellent point to an add-in. We are at the right time to let more audiences accept luxury fashion. (People have more buying power, the world is becoming richer) Defining the meaning of sustainable luxury in a socially responsible way. For the analyzing group, I will analyze the group of Chinese consumers presenting significantly in luxury fashion consumption worldwide. Exploring how to help them have a better understanding of fashion consumption’s environmental impact builds them a better consuming habit.
More importantly, from the company and government side, analyzing how to make some significant improvements for the whole textile industry: from the innovation for the materials to more sustainable distribution channels, marketing strategies about educating their end-customers in a meaningful environment-friendly manner. Defining the luxury fashion industry not only the cultural and economic meaning but also with a sustainable purpose. Find methods to make sustainability in the fashion industry become a reality.
Project aims and their relevance in the context of the state of the art
The project aims to give luxury fashion consumption a better meaning in terms of reaching SDG12. From the fashion company and government side, using communication strategies and technological innovation makes more people accept luxury with sustainable adding value. From the customer's side, to build sustainable proactive.
Group of people as an analyzing object: Chinese consumers in Europe
China’s growing economic power made the Chinese become the most essential luxury fashion shopping consumer globally. The group of Chinese makes a representation of luxury fashion shopping. Reported by Mckinsey 2019, "the Chinese consumers contributed almost two-thirds of global growth in luxury spending. In 2018 Chinese consumers spent a third of the global spend on luxury items ($115 billion). (McKinsey & Company, April 2019) “Chinese consumers will make more than half of the luxury goods purchases by 2025. Although the Chinese government is “pushing” for more local consumption, Chinese luxury sales in mainland China only made 11% of global sales in 2019; 40% of overall global sales are made when Chinese travel." (15th May 2020, Pamela N. Danziger).
"During and after the Covid-19, Bain predicted the personal luxury goods market would strike off 20% to 35% in 2020 and McKinsey is on record for sales to shrink as much as 35% to 39%. It predicts the industry will take more than two years to 2019 sales level. Claudia D'Arpizio (Bain’s partner in Milan, 2020, bain.com): China is the fashion luxury industry’s only hope. The economy in China will be the one that will be least impacted by the long tail of this planetary crisis. For the luxury market, the recovery will be stronger and faster in China than in the U.S. and Europe.” (15th May 2020, Pamela N. Danziger) Chinese overseas shopping in post-corona will impact the whole Luxury retail’s recovery. Chinese consumers in Milan and Paris are representing Chinese luxury shopping in Europe.
From another aspect, China will talk about: "rapid industrialization created costs to their public and environmental welfare, serious social, economic, and political problems. They are facing challenges in balancing economic growth with environmental and social welfare. High levels of air pollution take a major toll on public health." (chinapower.csis.org, 2020)
China has the economic friendly will: "China has a strong awareness of sustainability. They presented several significant commitments to addressing global climate change through the 2015 Paris agreement." (chinapower.csis.org, 2020) "The survey by Dutch research agency Motivaction: 64% Chinese considered them environmentalists, that is as twice as Europe and the States" (Anna Nicolaou, 7th May 2014)
China is an emerging country for luxury fashion goods; it is crucial to let Chinese consumers know the fashion textile industry’s negative environmental impact. To make their luxury fashion consumption with a better meaning in terms of sustainability and social consciousness, to build them healthier luxury fashion consumption habits, also value their luxury fashion shopping.
Location choice as an analyzing object
European brands, mostly European luxury brands, have been considered the most significant recognition. Milan and Paris are important fashion cities that attract many tourists every year through luxury fashion shopping, mostly Chinese tourists. It will give us vital data regarding the impact of shopping tourism facing Covid-19. Chinese consumers' behavior in Milan and Paris after the post-Covid-19 would also represent significantly how they consume luxury brands outside China.
The Covid-19 had a very negative impact on the whole luxury fashion industry since many manufacturers and shopping malls had to be closed during the lockdown time. “More than 40% of global luxury-good production is in Italy, and all the Italian factories have shut down temporarily.” (1st April 2020, Antonio Achille, Daniel Zipser) Moreover, the luxury industry is very adapted to the retailer; overseas tourists could not come to Europe for 'shopping' due to the sanitary emergency.
Defining the researching objects in different groups
1. Chinese tourists in Milan and Paris (the leading group of luxury fashion consumption),
2. Chinese migrations in Milan and Paris (who has lived here for many years, or even born here),
3. Chinese students in Milan and Paris (usually stay here for over one year but will leave Europe after),
4. Special group: Daigou代购 (a group of exporters outside China purchases commodities for consumers in China) in Milan and Paris
Geographically, they are from different geographic areas in China, which would help analyze the consumer’s cultural background and language preference. For example, people from Canton and Hong Kong speak Cantonese instead of Mandarin. The majority of the Chinese migrations in Paris and Milan are from Zhejiang province, south of China, etc.
Demographically, by analyzing gender, economic income, educational background, hobbies to define their luxury fashion shopping purpose. Find the possibility of adding sustainability into their consumption and how. Surveys will be used here to do the research.
Comparing also find the similarities between the Chinese consumers in Milan and Paris: find their favorite shopping brands (compare the different shopping behavior between them also make a comparison to those luxury fashion consumption inside mainland China)
Project description
Sustainability has been the big player in the fashion luxury industry's (LVMH, Kering, and Richmond) fundamental business model for at least three years. “LVMH's 2020 goals to procure 30 percent of its energy from renewable sources and reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 25% across its operations, despite sales growth.” (26 Sep 2019, Sarah Kent and Laure Guilbault) “Kering has developed an innovative tool for measuring and quantifying the environmental impact of its activities. The Environmental Profit & Loss (EP&L) account is a key enabler of a sustainable business model, and they are sharing it with other companies in the Luxury industry and other sectors.” (kering.com, 2020)
Luxury fashion companies lead the whole fashion industry; the rest imitate their fashion design, business strategies, communication strategies, etc. “Kering’s fashion pact (a global coalition of companies in the fashion and textile industry (ready-to-wear, sport, lifestyle and luxury) including their suppliers and distributors, all committed to a common core of key environmental goals in three areas: stopping global warming, restoring biodiversity and protecting the oceans” (thefashionpact.org, 2020), now has 56 companies together over 250 brands join them.” (kering.com, 2020). Luxury fashion companies sponsor many textiles innovation centers. They also lead the materials revolution in the fashion industry. On the fashion market, “There’s already a lot of clever companies that are starting to blend materials with hemp, ramie, or linen.” said the founder and director of The Sustainability Angle: Nina Marenzi. (BOF team and Mckinsey & Company, 2nd Jan 2020)
“Sustainable luxury is the future; it is not an eco-friendly product seeking a premium image but a luxury product with sustainable values. It is another option to save the planet since we would be channeling our purchasing power to where we might do the least harm-by buying sustainable luxury goods.” (Vivian Corporation, 14th Nov 2017)
Chinese customers are a chance for the luxury fashion industry. Even if the luxury companies don’t promote their products with a sustainable meaning, Chinese customers will purchase. But if luxury fashion companies promote it differently, it would greatly help in many different aspects. Chinese customers are very connected to the big fashion brands, mostly European brands. A wilder audience can know more about the textile industry's impacts on our natural environment. And also help them to define their luxury fashion purchasing with a completely different meaning. How can luxury fashion companies use business and technical innovation to attract different categories of Chinese consumers while collaborating with China (Chinese people) to make a voice to promote luxury with a sustainable meaning.
Methodology
This research will try to:
Measure and analyze the social-environmental impact of the fashion industry. By comparing luxury fashion and fast fashion’s meaning, the business strategy also researches a quantitative dimension of each environmental effect. Second-hand scientific data will be gathered in this research.
Together with the technical researching process published on kering.com (open resource), gathering the newest material and production innovation inside the supply chain. New sustainable alternative fabrics, less leather usage, recycled materials, etc. Complete research of the new materials and technical innovation will be present in this research.
Surveys online and in-person (purposive sampling) to Chinese luxury fashion consumers in Milan and Paris. Define them in different groups, analyzing them geographically also demographically—define their reason to buy and the conscious in terms of fashion's environmental impact.
Most significantly, educate end-customers to build a healthy consuming habit from a psychological point of view: help them buy valuable fashion goods and give luxury fashion consumers a sustainable adding value. From the existing luxury fashion's promotion, develop and define the right communication strategies to promote luxury fashion sustainably. (which channel would be the most suitable, in which way to present and how to explain) A qualitative and quantitative analysis will be present to analyze social media which is showing on different channels.
References
1. Anna Nicolaou, 7th May 2014, "in China, 64 percent say they are environmentalists - report", reuters.com, last reviewed on 30th August 2020 from https://www.reuters.com/article/us-environment-china/in-china-64-percent-say-they-are-environmentalists-report-idUSKBN0DN01H20140507
2. Antonio Achille, Daniel Zipser, (1st April 2020), mckinsey.com, “A perspective for the luxury goods industry during and after - coronavirus”, last reviewed on 20th August 2020 from https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/retail/our-insights/a-perspective-for-the-luxury-goods-industry-during-and-after-coronavirus
3. Bain.com, 2020, "Claudia D'Arpizio" https://www.bain.com/our-team/claudia-darpizio/
4. BOF team and Mckinsey & company, 2nd Jan 2020, "the year ahead, welcome to the material revolution", last reviewed on 1st Sep 2020 from https://www.businessoffashion.com/articles/intelligence/the-year-ahead-welcome-to-the-materials-revolution
5. Chinapower.csis.org, 2020, "is air quality in china a social problem?", last reviewed on 30th August 2020 from https://chinapower.csis.org/air-quality/
6. Kering.com, (2020), sustainability, last reviewed on 28th August from https://www.kering.com/en/sustainability/
7. Maynard, M. (2004) Dress and Globalisation, Manchester: Manchester University Press.
8. McKinsey & Company, (April 2019), mckinsey.com, “China luxury report 2019” last reviewed on 28th August 2020 from https://www.mckinsey.com/
9. Morgan McFall-Johnsen, (21 Oct 2019), businessinsider.com, “The fashion industry emits more carbon than international flights and maritime shipping combined. Here are the biggest ways it impacts the planet” last reviewed on 26th August 2020 from https://www.businessinsider.com/fast-fashion-environmental-impact-pollution-emissions-waste-water-2019-10?IR=T
10. Pamela N. Danziger (15th May 2020), “fate of luxury depends on China, but continued success there is not guaranteed”, last reviewed on 29th August 2020 from https://www.forbes.com/sites/pamdanziger/2020/05/15/fate-of-luxury-depends-on-china-but-continued-success-there-is-not-guaranteed/
11. Rabine, L.W. (2002) The Global Circulation of African Fashion, Oxford: Berg.
12. Rantisi, N. (2004) ‘The Designer in the City and the City in the Designer’ in D. Power and A.J. Scott (eds), Cultural Industries and the Production of Culture, New York: Routledge.
13. Thefashionpact.org (2020), “about the fashion pact”, last reviewed on 28th August 2020, from https://thefashionpact.org/?lang=en
14. Vivian Corporation, (14th Nov 2017) “what is a sustainable luxury”, last reviewed on 15th June 2020 from https://medium.com/@viviancorp/what-is-sustainable-luxury-b4df301e66d3